Ever since first glimpsing what has become our cozy crooked cottage, there was one thing about it that bothered me. When deciding whether or not to buy this house, my Pro/Con list looked something like this:
- 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths!
- Nearly 1 acre of yard!
- New windows!
- Updated flooring!
- All appliances included!
- …Popcorn ceiling.
One Con versus all the Pros isn’t bad at all, so we bought the house! But even in my staged photos after decorating, you can still tell that it’s THERE, yuck. I’ve thoroughly researched popcorn ceiling removal and have come up with a few options, but I can’t make up my mind! Here are my ideas:
1. Remove the popcorn ceiling.
Bloggers invariably agree, removing it yourself is the easiest, cheapest way to go. Popcorn ceiling is made out of a kind of shredded, crumbled cardboard. To remove, you just spray it down with water and then scrape it off. Seems simple enough, right? Some issues arise with this method. Houses built before 1978 potentially have asbestos in the “popcorn” bits. You’re supposed to scrape off a sample of the texture and send it away to an asbestos testing company for answers before beginning the project. If there’s no asbestos, green light! If they find asbestos, red light, and it will cost $$$ to have the texture professionally removed by guys in Hazmat suits. When I heard this (our house was built in 1970) I began viewing our potentially cancer-laden ceilings with fear… neeer ner ner ner, ner ner, ner ner CAN’T TOUCH THIS!
- The ceiling would have its smooth, pre-popcorn drywall texture.
- I could prime & paint the ceiling easily after the popcorn removal.
- Potential asbestos exposure.
- Our popcorn ceiling has been previously painted over in glossy white paint. This makes the whole “get it wet and scrape it off” thing more difficult- the water can’t soak in past the paint.
- The ENTIRE HOUSE has popcorn ceilings. This would be a project of epic proportions!
2. Cover the popcorn ceiling with bead board sheets.
Lowes sells 4′ x 8′ bead board sheets for about $20 a pop, and it would be easy enough to use a combo of liquid nails & regular nails to stick these up over top of the popcorn ceiling.
- The bead board would feel appropriately cottage-y.
- No potential asbestos exposure.
- We’d find out pretty fast if our home is square or not! And I’m betting not.
- I couldn’t do this by myself- lots of fancy saw-work for Mark, and it’s so hard to pin him down to a project these days.
- Expense- it would take probably 8 sheets to cover just the kitchen/living room, plus crown molding to make the edges seamless- you do the math.
3. Cover the popcorn ceiling with pallet wood.
(from here, tutorial included)
(from here. I would probably whitewash the pallet wood if I went with that option- more beachy)
I’ve seen several variations on a DIY-theme regarding old pallet wood. I’ve seen it used for accent walls, headboards, coffee tables, and now ceilings!
- No potential asbestos exposure.
- The wood would (haha) create an awesome rustic feeling.
- It’s green! We’d be reusing materials that would otherwise be thrown away.
- I could do the labor-intensive steps by myself, no man required=)
- It’s labor intensive.
- We’d lose a good inch off our already low (7’4″) ceilings.
- We can find the pallets for free, but would still need to purchase crown molding & corners.
4. Rip out the popcorn-covered drywall altogether, exposing attic beams.
(both pics from here)
What would you say if I told you that the ceiling height in the two pictures above is an even 7′? It looks so much higher than that! It’s a fabulously rustic look that would be perfect for the great room in our cozy little cottage.
- Instant character!
- Ceiling feels higher.
- It would be basically free- nothing being added, just taken out.
- It could look like crap under my drywall ceiling, I honestly have no idea.
- I wouldn’t be able to do this by myself! I would definitely would need to call in help for this idea.
- We would have to re-think the ceiling light fixtures- everything is exposed.
…See what I mean? They’re all good ideas, I just can’t decide what is BEST. Most likely (after I make up my mind) I’ll do the kitchen/living room first, to see how everything goes. We spend the majority of our time indoors in that “living area”- so updating the ceiling of one room will have a huge impact on the entire house.
Do you have any input for me on this project? Let me know which idea is your favorite!